Quick Answer: A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional (pre-tax) retirement account into a Roth account, and you pay income tax on the amount converted in the year you convert it. The most common traps people run into are: assuming they’ll be in a lower tax bracket in retirement, converting at the wrong time in the market, paying the conversion tax bill out of the retirement account itself instead of other savings, and overlooking how a conversion can affect Social Security taxation, Medicare premiums (IRMAA), the net investment income tax, and the Roth five-year rule. Whether a conversion makes sense depends on your income, your account balances, and your overall financial plan.
Why This Question Comes Up So Often
If you’ve spent years contributing to a 401(k), traditional IRA, or other pre-tax account, you’ve been deferring taxes, not avoiding them. Eventually, that money comes out, whether through a withdrawal you choose or a required minimum distribution (RMD) the IRS requires once you reach a certain age.
A lot of people assume their tax bracket will automatically be lower in retirement. That’s not always true. Between RMDs, pension income, Social Security, and other sources, some retirees end up in a similar or higher bracket than they expected. A Roth conversion is one way to address that, but it comes with its own set of rules and trade-offs worth understanding before you convert.
What Is a Roth Conversion?
A Roth conversion is the process of moving assets from a traditional IRA or other pre-tax retirement account into a Roth IRA. You owe ordinary income tax on the amount you convert in the year of the conversion. In exchange, that money — and its future growth — can potentially be withdrawn tax-free later, as long as certain requirements are met.
Whether a conversion is worthwhile depends heavily on your individual situation. Here are four traps to think through before you decide.
Trap 1: Assuming You’ll Automatically Be in a Lower Tax Bracket in Retirement
Many people convert — or avoid converting — based on the assumption that their tax bracket will drop once they stop working. That assumption doesn’t always hold up.
Required minimum distributions, pension income, and other income sources can push retirement income higher than expected. Before deciding on a conversion, it helps to look at:
- The current balance of your traditional IRA or 401(k)
- What your projected RMDs might look like once they begin
- Any pension or other guaranteed income you’ll receive
- How those income sources fit into your overall financial plan
Online calculators can give you a rough idea of future RMD amounts, but reviewing the full picture with a financial professional can help you see how a conversion might affect your specific plan.
A related reason some people convert: if your children or other heirs are likely to be in a higher tax bracket than you are, converting during your lifetime may allow you to pay tax at your own rate rather than passing a fully taxable traditional IRA on to them.
Trap 2: Ignoring the Timing of the Market
A down market is often seen as bad news, but it can also create an opportunity. If you convert shares from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA while the market is down, you may owe less tax on the conversion than you would if the same shares were converted at a higher value. Once the assets are in the Roth account, any future growth has the potential to be tax-free.
A few practical notes if you’re considering this approach:
- Confirm your custodian can transfer shares directly from a traditional to a Roth account, rather than requiring you to sell and rebuy.
- If you’re converting cash instead of shares, be mindful of the wash sale rule if you plan to repurchase the same investments shortly after selling.
Trap 3: Paying the Tax Bill From the Wrong Account
One of the most overlooked decisions in a Roth conversion is where the tax payment comes from. It’s often preferable to pay the tax bill using funds from a brokerage account or other non-retirement savings, rather than withholding taxes from the IRA itself.
Withholding taxes from the account you’re converting reduces the amount that actually reaches the Roth, which can reduce the long-term benefit of the conversion. Depending on your full financial picture, converting using funds withheld from the account may still make sense — but the numbers generally work out better when the tax bill is paid from outside the retirement account.
Trap 4: Overlooking the Ripple Effects on Other Taxes — and the Five-Year Rule
A Roth conversion doesn’t happen in isolation. It can affect other parts of your tax picture, including:
- Social Security taxation. Depending on your income level, a conversion could affect how much of your Social Security benefit is subject to tax.
- IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount). This is a surcharge on Medicare premiums that applies at higher income levels. Unlike a one-time penalty, an IRMAA surcharge applies for a full year, based on income reported from an earlier tax year. A large, one-time conversion can be more likely to trigger this than smaller conversions spread across multiple years.
- Net investment income tax. This is an additional tax on investment income that applies above certain income thresholds.
Because these thresholds are tied to specific dollar amounts that can change from year to year, it’s worth confirming current limits with a tax professional before finalizing a conversion strategy.
Finally, there’s the Roth five-year rule. Each Roth IRA is subject to a five-year holding period before certain earnings can be withdrawn tax-free, and each conversion can start its own five-year clock. Depending on your age and when you expect to use the money, this rule may or may not be a major factor. If you don’t plan to touch converted funds for ten, fifteen, or twenty years, it may matter less than it would for someone planning to withdraw sooner.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming your tax bracket will be lower in retirement without reviewing actual income sources
- Converting a large amount all at once without considering IRMAA or other income-based thresholds
- Paying the conversion tax bill from the retirement account being converted
- Forgetting that each conversion can restart a five-year holding period
- Making the decision without checking your emergency fund first — converted assets generally shouldn’t be a source of near-term cash flow
Questions to Ask Before You Convert
- What will my required minimum distributions look like, and when will they start?
- Do I have other income sources that could push me into a higher bracket in retirement?
- Can I pay the tax bill on the conversion without touching the funds being converted?
- How might this affect my Social Security taxation, Medicare premiums, or the net investment income tax?
- Does it make more sense to convert a smaller amount over several years instead of one large amount?
- Do I have enough set aside in an emergency fund so I’m not relying on newly converted assets for near-term expenses?
How Financial Planning May Help
A Roth conversion touches several parts of a financial plan at once — retirement accounts, current-year taxes, Medicare premiums, and estate considerations, among others. Reviewing these factors together, rather than in isolation, can help you see how a conversion might fit into your broader goals and where the trade-offs are.
Buffalo First Wealth Management works with clients to look at retirement account balances, projected income, and tax considerations as part of ongoing financial planning and proactive tax planning. If you’re weighing a Roth conversion, a conversation with your financial and tax professionals is a reasonable next step before making a decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Roth conversion right for everyone? No. Whether a conversion makes sense depends on factors such as your current and projected income, the size of your pre-tax accounts, your age, and your broader financial and estate goals.
Do I pay taxes when I convert to a Roth IRA? Yes. The amount converted is generally treated as ordinary income in the year of the conversion.
Can a Roth conversion affect my Medicare premiums? It can. Income from a conversion may increase your modified adjusted gross income, which is a factor used to determine IRMAA surcharges on Medicare premiums.
What is the Roth five-year rule? It’s a holding-period requirement that can affect whether certain withdrawals from a Roth account are tax-free. Each conversion can start its own five-year period, depending on your age and account history.
Should I convert all at once or over several years? Spreading a conversion over multiple years is one strategy some people use to help manage the effect on their tax bracket, Social Security taxation, and IRMAA. Whether that approach fits your situation depends on your specific numbers.
Talk Through Your Roth Conversion Questions
Every situation is different, and a Roth conversion strategy that works well for one household may not work for another. If you’re trying to figure out whether a Roth conversion fits your plan, Buffalo First Wealth Management can help you look at the full picture.
Stay tuned for our next post.
Need Help With Your Roth Conversion?
Schedule a consultation with Buffalo First Wealth Management to talk through your retirement account options.